• Home
  • Donate
  • Contact
  • Log In

Secular Student Alliance eMpirical No. 43: Many Meetings

eMpirical, the newsletter of the Secular Student AllianceMarch 10, 2010

In this issue:

Don't like scrolling? Check out the teasers-only version of the eMpirical.

The SSA only exists because of your support. Please donate today.
Secular shorts:
Didn't make it to the Northern California Leadership Summit? Check out the videos on the SSA's YouTube channel!

Topic and deadlines announced for the Freedom From Religion Foundation 2010 Student Essay Contest!

The NonProphet Status wants to hear your secular story as part of their Share Your Secular Story Contest.

Canadian Affiliates! Don't miss the first-ever CFI Canada National Conference.

Going somewhere? Support the Secular Student Alliance while you go. Book travel through our travel gateway.

Buy your books (and other gear) through Amazon to support the Secular Student Alliance!

Contact us!
Call us toll free at 1-877-842-9474. You can also email us at ssa@secularstudents.org. We are always happy to hear from you and answer any questions or concerns!

What do you think?
This is your eNewsletter and we are always updating and changing to fit your needs, so please let us know what you think of our new format! Email enews@secularstudents.org with any suggestions, ideas, or comments.

eMpirical Team

Content Manager:
Frank Bellamy

Editors: August E. Brunsman IV, Ait Chapel, Amanda Knief, Lyz Liddell, Hemant Mehta, Luis A. Morán Morales

Communications Director:
Jesse Galef

Introduction

It's an exciting time to be involved in the secular student movement - there's more going on than ever! We just held our Northern California Leadership Summit (a great success!) and we're gearing up for the New England Leadership Summit in April. And just a few weeks ago, we participated in a historic meeting between nontheist leaders and officials from the White House. Check out all the great work our affiliates have been up to, and don't miss out on all the opportunities available to freethinking students.


SSA New England Leadership Summit

The Secular Student Alliance is proud to announce its New England Leadership Summit, to be held April 16-18, 2010. The summit will be hosted at Harvard University in Boston, MA. This weekend session is a great opportunity for student leaders to fine-tune their group-running skills, meet other leaders from the area, network with local off-campus organizations, and have a great time!

We're excited to be holding this event in conjunction with the Harvard Humanist Chaplaincy's award ceremony for the Outstanding Lifetime Achievement Award in Cultural Humanism, being presented this year to the MythBusters. Join us for the award ceremony at a special discounted rate of only $8 when you register through the New England Leadership Summit.

Harvard

Registration
Registration for the New England Leadership Summit is only $25 for students who are members of the SSA. You can also register through our site for a special $8 rate for the MythBusters on Humanism event on Friday night. Nonstudents and nonmembers are also welcome to join us for a weekend of training, networking and fun!

Registration Rates ( register online!)

  • Student SSA Members: $25.00
  • Student Nonmembers: $75.00
  • Nonstudent SSA Members: $125.00
  • Nonstudent Nonmembers: $200.00
  • Special SSA Registration for the MythBusters on Humanism: $8.00

Being a member of an SSA affiliate group is separate from being a member of the national Secular Student Alliance. Join the SSA and save: www.secularstudents.org/join.

Register online!

Housing Information
Housing for the New England Leadership Summit is not being provided as part of the conference due to high bookings in the area for the Boston Marathon. However, we have found several hotel options in the Harvard Square area or within easy bus/subway travel that you can check out.

Hostelling International Boston Downtown (~3 miles from Harvard; bus or subway)
12 Hemenway Street, Boston, MA 02115
Phone: (617) 536-1027
Reservations: bostonhostel@bostonhostel.org
Rates: $44.99 per person

Sheraton Commander Hotel (short walking distance)
16 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138
Reservations: (800) 535-5007
email: sales@shreratoncommander.com
Rates: $199 and up (rates vary; check with hotel)

Inn At Harvard Square (short walking distance)
1201 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA, 02138
Reservations: (800) 458-5886
Rates: $249 and up

Best Western Hotel Tria (1.6 miles from Harvard; bus or subway)
220 Alewife Brook Parkway, Cambridge, MA, 2138
Phone: (617) 491-8000 or 866-333-TRIA
Rates: $135 and up - Friday / $212 and up - Weekend

Homewood Suites by Hilton Cambridge-Arlington (2.4 miles from Harvard)
1 Massachusetts Ave., Arlington, MA 02474
Phone: (781) 643-7258
Rates: $199 and up

Boston Marriott Cambridge (3.5 miles from Harvard)
Two Cambridge Center, 50 Broadway
Cambridge, MA 02142
Phone: (617) 494-6600
Rates: $249 and up



Travel Grants

We have travel grants available to help defray costs of travel and lodging for the summit. Travel grants are available in the amount of $100. Students receiving travel grants must be SSA members and must be registered for the conference. Checks must be picked up in person at the conference.

Students who receive a travel grant are required to complete a short write-up (about 500 words) about their experience at the conference. We must receive these essays within one month of the conference. These essays may be published in our electronic newsletter, on our website, or in publicity materials.

Apply for a Travel Grant at http://www.secularstudents.org/node/2889.

Program & Schedule
The New England Leadership Summit runs from Friday evening to Sunday afternoon, 4/16/2010 - 4/18/2010.
Friday, 4/16
8pm: MythBusters On Humanism Presented by Harvard Secular Society & Harvard Humanist Chaplaincy, at the Memorial Church on the Harvard Yard, Cambridge.

Saturday, 4/17 All events in Fong Auditorium, Boylston Hall, Harvard University
10:00am: Registration opens
10:30am: Events begin
12:30pm: Break for lunch
1:30pm: Events resume
6:00pm: Break for dinner - on your own
8:00pm: Keynote Presentation

Sunday, 4/18
10:30am: Events begin
2:00pm: Regional Summit Closes

MythBusters on Humanism
The Annual Outstanding Lifetime Achievement Award in Cultural Humanism is presented at Harvard University each year by the Harvard Secular Society on behalf of the Humanist Chaplaincy at Harvard and the American Humanist Association. Selected by a committee of 20-30 Harvard students each year, this award is given to a figure greatly admired by our students and community for both artistic and humanitarian reasons.

Now in its fourth year, the HSS Cultural Humanism committee has chosen the recipients for the award, the MythBusters, based on what they feel is an outstanding contribution to Humanism in culture. The MythBusters - special-effects experts Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman - take on the task of separating truth from urban legend on their television show with the same name. In true Humanist style, the pair takes on three myths per episode and uses modern-day science to demonstrate, through scientific trials, whether or not some things we take for granted really hold any ground. The award ceremony (April 16 8:00pm Memorial Church) will feature a talk and demonstrations by the pair.

Previous winners of the Cultural Humanism Award are, in 2007, novelist Sir Salman Rushdie, in 2008, punk rock star Greg Graffin (of the band Bad Religion and the UCLA Faculty of Biology), and in 2009, writer/ director/producer Joss Whedon ("Buffy," "Angel," Firefly," "Dollhouse").

Tickets to this event, when purchased as part of the SSA's New England Leadership Summit, are only $8 each! Reserve your seat when you register for the summit.

Advertising with the SSA
The Secular Student Alliance offers unique advertising opportunities for freethought organizations, businesses and authors. We offer opportunities to table at our regional leadership summits, and have opportunities for full-page, full-color advertisements in the conference proceedings booklets distributed to all conference attendees.

Tables for this event are $75.00 for the full weekend, including one free "Exhibitor" registration to the event. You can reserve a table at the 2010 New England Leadership Summit through our online webform.

You may place a 8.5 x 11, full color ad in our conference proceedings at one of three levels. Placing your ad in the proceedings for the New England Leadership Summit is $50.00 - ideal for local off-campus organizations! You may place an ad in the proceedings for our National Conference in summer 2010 for $75.00. Or, you can place your ad in both for a discounted rate of $100.00 - a great solution for authors, online businesses and national organizations. Reserve your ad space using our convenient webform!

Reserve a Table

Place a Conference Proceedings Ad




Spring 2010 Affiliation Renewal



It's time for the Secular Student Alliance's Spring 2010 Affiliation Renewal! This is the semiannual survey which we administer to all our student groups in order to make sure you're still alive, see what you've been up to, and find out how we have (or haven't) been able to help.

Every SSA affiliate group is required to complete the Affiliation Renewal in order to remain affiliated with the SSA. (Even if you just affiliated last week!) If I do not receive a renewal form from your group, I will be contacting you to find out what happened! But you can save us both the game of phone tag if you just take the time this week to complete the form.

Your group can win a $50 EvolveFISH gift certificate if you complete your Affiliation Renewal by 11:59pm on Tuesday, March 9th, 2010. On Wednesday morning, we'll hold a drawing from the eligible groups to see who wins each of our two $50 gift certificates for the popular EvolveFISH.com store.

If your group is no longer active, you do not need to complete the affiliation renewal. Please reply to this email and let me know your school, group name, and (if possible) any reasons that your group is no longer active. Knowing why our groups stop being active can help us better support our affiliates in the future.

Be prepared. The spring Affiliation Renewal is longer than the one you filled out last fall. We highly recommend that before you get started on the real form, you take a look at the Affiliation Renewal Preview in order to gather the information you'll need. There is no way to save the form midway, so you'll want to allow 5-10 minutes to complete the form and have your information ready when you start.

Don't work too hard. We only need one renewal form per group, but this email goes out to all our listed group leaders and advisors. Be sure you talk with your other officers to make sure you aren't filling out the form multiple times.

If you have any questions about the Affiliation Renewal, please feel free to contact me! I would far prefer to answer your questions than have to chase you down because I didn't hear from you.


Renew Your Affiliation Today!
https://secularstudents.wufoo.com/forms/ssa-spring-2010-affiliation-renewal/






Openings for Secular Student Alliance Board of Directors



The Secular Student Alliance is looking for dedicated leaders who would like to run for positions on the SSA's Board of Directors! The SSA is a democratic organization and all SSA members are eligible to run for a position on the Board of Directors. Elections take place this May, and board terms are two years long.

Board members are responsible for setting goals and policy for the organization, fundraising, reviewing progress, and promoting SSA. All Board members are expected to participate in fundraising. We are happy to train you to do this, but you must be willing.

We have monthly phone meetings and also have a face-to-face meeting once a year--typically in July. We ask only people who foresee being able to participate in at least 9 of the 12 phone meetings and the face-to-face meeting to run for the Board of Directors.

We would like to especially encourage students or recent students who have proven experience with their own campus groups and are eager to become involved at the national level to run. This is a serious, volunteer time commitment, but it is worthwhile for those looking to remain active in the secular movement.

If you are interested in running, or would like to know more about the election process, please send an email (hemant(AT)secularstudents(DOT)org) with a brief bio (around 200 words) and phone number by Friday, March 12, 2010.

The Bylaws governing our elections are available at
http://www.secularstudents.org/sites/default/files/SSA_bylaws_20090106.pdf.





Ted Cox and Matt Dillahunty Join SSA Speakers Bureau


The Secular Student Alliance is pleased to announce that we have added Mormon-turned-atheist Ted Cox and atheist activist Matt Dillahunty to our Speakers Bureau. The Speakers Bureau consists of freethought speakers who have graciously offered to speak / present / debate on your campus for free, provided you are an official affiliate of the Secular Student Alliance. Learn more about the Bureau at Ted Coxwww.secularstudents.org/speakers.

Ted Cox

Ted Cox is a former Mormon missionary who became an atheist after taking a college class in Biology. In 2007, he went undercover in Christian gay-to-straight therapy programs and is currently writing a book about his experiences. As a frequent contributor to the Sacramento News & Review, Ted has written about religion, sex, the environment and furries. Ted speaks on topics including his experiences going undercover in Christian gay-to-straight programs, and just about anything related to Mormonism.

Matt DillahuntyMatt Dillahunty
Matt has served as President of The Atheist Community of Austin since 2005, co-hosts the group's atheist-oriented podcast, The Non-Prophets, and hosts the group's public access television program, The Atheist Experience. The program is a 90-minute, live, weekly program that takes live calls from listeners in Austin and around the world, prompting many debates and discussions on a variety of religious, philosophical and skeptical topics. He's been hosting for the program since 2004 and, thanks to fans posting clips on YouTube, the show has broken out of the Austin public access arena and is available to the world as a live stream and podcast.

If you are interested in having either of these speakers come present at your campus, please contact the campus organizer at organizer@secularstudents.org, or fill out our online Speaker Request form.


Atheist Students and Leaders Participate in White House Briefing

The atheist movement made a big step last Friday when the Secular Coalition for America arranged a policy briefing with White House officials. A delegation of about 60 nontheists convened in the nation's capital to engage with the administration. I can't repeat what the administration said - these meetings are held off the record - but I can say that I've never felt more proud and optimistic about the political status of atheists.

Photo of Secular Student Alliance at White House briefing. Februrary 2010.

The Secular Student Alliance delegation inside the briefing room. Left to right: Catherine Blackwell, president of SSA at UMBC; Lyz Liddell, Director of Campus Organizing; Hemant Mehta, Chair of the Board; Jesse Galef, Director of Communications; Matthew LaClair, Board Member; August Brunsman, Executive Director; Shelley Mountjoy, Board Member.

The topics we focused on were: protecting children from religiously-motivated medical neglect, ending the coercive religious climate in the military, and fixing the faith-based initiatives. To discuss the issues, we met with representatives from the departments of Health and Human Services, Defense, and Justice. My friend Paul Fidalgo, now a spokesman for the Secular Coalition for America, told reporters that we were "encouraged by the reception we got today" and said the meeting went "very, very well." I have to agree.

While various groups have been treated to this sort of meeting before, it was the first time our community was recognized as deserving the same treatment. That's the key point: we're hoping for secular Americans to be a part of the political process like all the other religious identities. Leaders of religious communities frequently get to speak with administration officials; we want the same thing. It seems only fair.

A quick point about expectations: try to remember that we are one group among many. True, secular Americans are a sizable minority, but we don't - and won't - call all the shots. Some people complain to me that the administration isn't perfect on our issues. Well, duh. We can hope for perfection and work toward it, but it's not reasonable to expect. It is, however, reasonable to expect and demand that we be recognized as part of the process and that our voices be heard. And it's starting to happen.

Most of the reaction in the media - and there's a lot! - is even-handed and represents us accurately. Story (McClatchy) after story (USA Today) after story (Washington Post) after story (ABC News) mentioned the meeting's novelty and listed our concerns.

And then there's the expected teeth-gnashing from religious zealots (such as my old friend Bill Donohue.) But the real prize for crazy response goes to Hannity, whose mangling of reality is breathtaking (from MediaMatters):

HANNITY: The Obama administration earlier today rolled out the red carpet for a coalition of atheist groups. Now, among the individuals in attendance was Michael Newdow. That's the California man who sued unsuccessfully to have the words "under God" removed from the Pledge of Allegiance. Now, religious groups, however, have not received this kind of treatment from the Obama White House. Now, last year, the President distanced himself from the National Day of Prayer, cancelling the formal service traditionally held in honor of the day and refusing to attend a Catholic prayer breakfast. So what's going on? Has the administration demonstrated a pattern of hostility towards religion, or is this merely a coincidence?

Media Matters does a great job demonstrating that religious groups HAVE received this kind of treatment from the Obama administration. Actually, they often receive better treatment - Obama met personally with religious leaders.

The truth of the matter is that religion is starting to lose its unfair position of privilege in American government. That change appears to be scaring some people. Expect more terrified flailing in the future, because we're gaining momentum in our campaign for equal treatment. Friday's meeting was a big step, but we're going to accomplish so much more.

(Image from August Brunsman)

Photo of Jesse GalefJesse Galef is the Communications Director for the Secular Student Alliance. He has worked for the Secular Coalition for America and the American Humanist Association.



Review: SSA's 2010 Northern California Leadership Summit

by Jason Cooperrider

This past February, I had the pleasure of attending the Secular Student Alliance's Northern California Leadership Summit at Stanford University in Palo Alto, California. It was my honor to represent SHIFT (Secular Humanism, Inquiry and Freethought), the secular student group at the University of Utah, as its president and co-founder.

Though I had heard about the leadership summit for several weeks before it occurred, I had not planned to attend, due to prior commitments I had made to my graduate program for the same weekend. However, after receiving a personal invitation from Lyz Liddell, who said she would really like to have representation there from our group, I decided that we must have a presence there, so that our group might benefit from the knowledge and ideas that would certainly be provided at the conference. Because no one else in our group was able to attend, I decided to petition my graduate program to allow me to shirk my duties in order to attend the conference, and I am very glad I did.


Austin Dacey delivers the keynote address "A Secular Calling" in the Memorial Church at Stanford University.

This was my first national event for the secular movement and it was a very rewarding experience. There was not a single talk given throughout the conference that I thought was boring or worthless. To the contrary, I found them all to be very entertaining and beneficial, such that I was able to derive some amusement and wisdom from each and every one. There were some great talks by leading national figures of the secular movement, such as Sean Faircloth from the Secular Coalition for America and Dr. Austin Dacey formerly of the United Nations. I was also highly impressed by the caliber of talks given by the student attendees, most of whom are undergraduate students.

The conference was filled with a spirit of cooperation and friendship, such that I felt comfortable with and greatly enjoyed talking with everyone present.

Students and speakers at the Northern California Leadership Summit pose for a group photo in front of the Rodin sculpture "Gates of Hell."

There was a sense of importance and of a pending revolution that would be made possible by those attending the conference and by many others just like them from around the world, such that secularism would prevail over religious dogma within the lifetimes of many who were present. I brought back with me many great ideas and suggestions that will benefit our group, some that have already been implemented and some that we intend to implement in the near future.
I am very thankful for the friendships that I forged and for the knowledge that I gained during my time at the conference. I thank the SSA for organizing the event and providing me with a travel grant to aid in the costs associated with my attendance, AHA! @ Stanford for being such wonderful hosts, and everyone involved for making the conference so successful and memorable for me. I look forward to participating in other national SSA events in the future.

Jason Cooperrider is the president and co-founder of SHIFT (Secular Humanism, Inquiry and Freethought) at the University of Utah, where he is pursuing a Ph.D. in neuroscience.





Freethinking Healer and Rabble-Rouser Helen Kagin dies at 76

Helen KaginA beloved freethinking activist, and member of the Secular Student Alliance, passed away on February 17 th, 2010 after a long battle with cancer. Helen worked as a physician in Cincinnati, OH for over thirty years.

I had the pleasure and honor of knowing Helen for just shy of eleven years. The joy, intensity, and brilliance with which she lived her life are totally impossible to capture in words. At Camp Quest Ohio, most of the kids and younger counselors played this vigorous, no-holds-barred version of keep away in the pool with a ball. There was no leader, no ref, no written rules, no score keeping. It just came together organically, summer after summer. With a small handful of exceptions, only the youngest staffers played with any regularity. Well into her seventies, Helen could be counted on to play every time her and the ball were in the pool at the same time.

Helen was a long time member and supporter of the Secular Student Alliance. The last time I saw her was at our 2009 conference on the campus of Ohio State University.

Helen and Edwin retire from CQ Ohio in 2005In humanist and atheist circles, Helen is best known for starting Camp Quest with her husband Edwin Kagin in 1996. Edwin and Helen were jointly named "Atheist of the Year" by American Atheists in 2005 for their work starting and running Camp Quest. Helen was the registrar and quartermaster of the Ohio camp until she retired from Camp Quest in 2005.

Memorial gifts can be given to the Helen Kagin Memorial Campership Fund of Camp Quest Inc. by mailing them to Camp Quest Inc., P.O. Box 2552, Columbus, OH 43216, with the notation "Kagin Fund." Donations may also be made on the Camp Quest Web site, www.camp-quest.org.

A trouble-maker (in the most noble sense of that word) to the end, Helen manged to upset the Creation Museum even with her obituary. Her obituary mentioned her work in organizing the Rally for Reason that protested the opening of the Creation Museum.

In addition to the pool game, the thing that may stay with me the most about Helen, is my memory of her leading us singing the Phil Ochs song "When I'm Gone".

Helen and others sign at Camp Quest Ohio
Part of it goes...
"And I won't be laughing at the lies when I'm gone
And I can't question how or when or why when I'm gone
Can't live proud enough to die when I'm gone
So I guess I'll have to do it while I'm here"

Helen did.

--
August E. Brunsman IV is the executive director of the Secular Student Alliance and has volunteered with Camp Quest Ohio since 1999. He is now the volunteer camp director of the Ohio camp. He is also the Secretary of the Secular Coalition for America.





A Polite Response to an Impolite Article

Lucy Gubbins is the president of the Alliance of Happy Atheists, a secular student group at the University of Oregon. In January, their campus newspaper made the strange decision to reprint an anti-atheist screed which had first been published at Portland State University three months earlier. Lucy mobilized her group to respond with polite letters to the editor. Here's the letter she got printed:

Reprinting anti-atheism commentary offensive, lacking balance

Lucy Gubbins, President of the UO Alliance of Happy Atheists

By Lucy Gubbins | President, Alliance of Happy Atheists

A long-time fan of the Oregon Daily Emerald, I was deeply surprised to open up the year's second issue to find Dick Richards' "Knocking atheism off its pedestal" as the off-campus commentary in the opinion section.

An ardent supporter of free speech and an equally ardent supporter of discourse between the religious and secular - two groups which have, for far too long, been alienated from each other - I was saddened and deeply disappointed by the ODE staff's lapse of judgment in deciding to reprint this article.

Wading through such journalistic gems as "idiots" and "dipshits" (in reference to atheists), I was unimpressed and bored by this "flamebait" of an article, which served no purpose but to present the author's obvious and unabashed hate for the non-religious community. It gave the reader no argument, no information, no nothing; it was simply an uninteresting, uneducated diatribe that read more like a mildly offensive YouTube comment than the legitimate article that should have been in its place.

While I wasn't bothered by the article itself, I am bothered - and bewildered - by the fact that the ODE decided to run this article (three months after its original publication) in this issue, with no opposing view or added commentary included. Here's to hoping that the ODE staff re-evaluates the process by which they choose off-campus commentaries. And here's to hoping, too, that Mr. Richards finds some happiness in his life. Maybe he should come to one of our meetings.

Lucy's letter on the Oregon Daily Emerald website can be found here.

The original article by Dick Richards can be found here.






Dealing with Disaster: Darwin Day 2010 at GMU

Friday, February 12th, 2010 was the 201st Anniversary of the birth of Charles Darwin. Commonly called "Darwin Day," it is a great chance for our community to gather to celebrate humanity and science.

At George Mason University, the Office of Student Activities will approve funding for food at only one event per year. What would be more appropriate for a non-religious group than a Flying Spaghetti Monster Pasta Dinner? So, I filled out the necessary paperwork so that our group, the Secular Student Alliance (GMU), could host a pasta dinner. Another leader in our group made arrangements for a speaker, and our group planned to celebrate Darwin Day with what would have been a fabulous pasta dinner and awesome guest lecture.

The weather had different plans, though. Snowmageddon '10 hit and our pasta extravaganza became 15 pizzas. The dinner was scheduled for Friday and inclement weather had closed the school Monday through Thursday.

In the end, everything worked out. Our speaker was still able to make it and the people who did come enjoyed the event. Nevertheless, as president of the Secular Student Alliance (GMU), I was left thinking about two questions:

1. Are we becoming too "religious" in our rituals to honor his noodly appendage?

As a result of a week of closures there was no time for campus catering to prepare the dinner we had planned. Nevertheless, Student Activities went out of their way to help provide some food that evening-specifically Papa John's Pizza.

I notified those signed up on Facebook and Meetup that we would have food-just not the pasta planned-so that they wouldn't be disappointed when they arrived. Ironically, pizza is actually more popular than pasta, and, had we marketed this event as a pizza dinner, the student turnout likely would have been higher.

The pasta dinner would have been fully catered. With the changes came increased paperwork and the need for me to buy soda and paper products, and set up. While I was busy running last minute errands a debate emerged.The pasta dinner would have been fully catered. With the changes came increased paperwork and the need for me to buy soda and paper products, and set up. While I was busy running last minute errands a debate emerged.

I was happy with the accommodations, but to some, the lack of pasta was extremely disappointing. One of our student leaders wanted to push for pasta and in the end purchased pasta with personal funds. Most of it remained uneaten.

I understand the connection between the Flying Spaghetti Monster and pasta dinner. It would have been nice to have pasta, but it's more logical, in my mind, to do what is practical. So, is this an issue? Do we need to celebrate the FSM with pasta? Should we have fought for pasta like other students fight for accommodations for their religious beliefs? If so, it sounds like dogma to me. The FSM is not a real religion and therefore we should be able to adjust our rituals as necessary.

2. Should an event be canceled, or rescheduled, in consideration of inclement weather cancellations earlier in the week?

We still had the guest speaker-Tim Farley from whatstheharm.net-although we were significantly delayed in getting him to campus with heavy traffic on recently plowed streets. The turnout was less than half of what we expected.

Student and community members who were off campus had no intention of coming on campus for a free meal when they had been home all week and were coming up on the weekend. Students who were on campus didn't get exposure to the advertising we would have normally done. We had intended to have a kiosk in a major building on campus. However, that building, and in many others we had hung flyers in, were closed all week.

If we rescheduled, we would have had to find a new speaker since the 2/12 date corresponded with Tim's travel plans. Regardless, I feel we should have postponed the dinner.

A major part of holding an event is to build recognition of the student group. Even people who cannot attend see that there is a party with free food, a great speaker, and-most importantly-there is a Secular Student Alliance group on campus! This didn't happen. A few of our existing members did bring along friends, but new faces were largely absent from the event.

Also, at the end of the day I was left holding the ball. There was no one to toss the ball to because no one was anticipating drastic last minute changes. Should one student leader struggle with paperwork, a bulk pizza order, a trip to the grocery store, and room set up by herself on the day of the event? For a student leader in a wheelchair, such as myself, this was next to impossible. I'm amazed that it all came together. Although even for an able-bodied student leader I still would have recommended rescheduling the event. This is too much work for one student to carry-especially in one day.

What is the best course of action for a student group whose event is affected by inclement weather? In our situation, just because campus had finally reopened after a week of closures it didn't mean that we needed to go through with the event as planned. I wrote this article because many of us feel the need to continue with plans despite the changes and to focus on the positive rather than contemplate the negative. Sometimes our expectation to follow through despite bumps in the road becomes an obligation to charge on regardless of obstacles. This doesn't have to be the only option.

Shelley Mountjoy photoShelley Mountjoy is a graduate student at the George Mason University in Fairfax, VA. She is the founder and president of the Secular Student Alliance (GMU), the vice president of the Graduate and Professional Student Association ( GAPSA) and a board member of the Secular Student Alliance. She lives in Central Virginia with her cat, Sarah.






SHIFT Celebrates Carl Sagan Day



On Saturday, November 7, 2009, Secular Humanism, Inquiry and Freethought ( SHIFT) at the University of Utah, celebrated what would have been the 75 th birthday of Carl Sagan, famed astronomer, skeptic, activist, and writer. Sagan was born on November 9, 1934 and was lost to the world on December 20, 1996. During his 62 years on our planet, Sagan inspired many people and had a significant impact on our world. He was a brilliant scientist, primarily in the field of planetary astrophysics, and had an uncanny talent for explaining scientific ideas to and popularizing science for the general public. He did this through his books, interviews, talks, and popular television series, Cosmos. In 1980, Sagan co-founded The Planetary Society, which continues its original mission of promoting space science, travel, and colonization. He was also one of the pioneering (and lifelong) proponents of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence ( SETI).

Photo of John Belz talking about Carl Sagan's areas of research during Carl Sagan Day 2009 celebration at University of Utah.

Physics professor John Belz talking about Carl Sagan's areas of research.

After receiving the suggestion in a mass email from the Center for Inquiry to celebrate Carl Sagan Day, the leaders of SHIFT decided that Carl Sagan is certainly worth honoring. Like SHIFT, Sagan's goal was to proclaim the greatness of science and reason so everyone might have a better understanding of the amazing universe we inhabit. He sought meaning in life through an understanding of the universe itself, not in the faith and dogma preached by religions. Sagan championed science and reason in both his fiction and nonfiction works. His authored and coauthored books include The Demon-Haunted World, Pale Blue Dot, Cosmos, Billions and Billions, Contact, and his Pulitzer-winning The Dragons of Eden, just to name a few.

SHIFT celebrated Carl Sagan Day with astronomy-themed food, such as Starburst fruit chews, Milky Way bars, and Sunkist fruit snacks, along with flying saucer-shaped pita bread to dip in hummus. After refreshments, SHIFT screened Contact, the film based on Sagan's novel (Sagan and his wife also wrote the outline for the film adaptation).

Contact follows a brilliant SETI researcher, Ellie Arroway, who discovers a signal from somewhere near the star Vega, which is 26 light years from Earth. The signal is a retransmission of the first television signal strong enough to travel beyond Earth's atmosphere: Adolf Hitler's opening speech at the 1936 Summer Olympics in Berlin. Within that signal, however, is embedded a prime number sequence to demonstrate intelligence via the understanding of mathematics, the universal language, and the three-dimensional designs for what seems to be a device that will allow advanced human space travel for one occupant at a time. After overcoming persecution for her lack of theistic beliefs, Ellie is eventually selected to be the representative from Earth to use the device to travel to those who had sent the signal. Her journey is successful, but very few people believe her claims about meeting the aliens because she was only gone for a fraction of a second in Earth time. She seemed to have gone nowhere at all and had no empirical evidence for her journey to prove what she had experienced. The movie contains many important messages about the nature of faith and the importance of science and reason.

To conclude the event, John Belz, PhD, from the University of Utah Department of Physics and Astronomy, gave a presentation on the life, science, and beliefs of Carl Sagan, and described how Sagan influenced him to become a scientist. Belz told us that, until he, as a child, first saw Sagan on the television show Cosmos, he thought that scientists were all rich people doing neat experiments and research funded by their own money. However, after hearing Sagan talk about the wonders of science, he decided that he would become a scientist himself, specifically, an astrophysicist like Sagan. So, it is largely thanks to Sagan that Belz became the scientist he is today, researching cosmic rays via the University of Utah's High Resolution Fly's Eye cosmic ray observatory. Belz's presentation was very interesting, especially when he was discussing some of the ways that Sagan, despite tirelessly promoting science and reason, was himself somewhat of a "mystic and spiritualist." Sagan derived his "spirituality" from the glories of the universe itself and the patterns it contained, rather than from belief in a supreme being.

Photo of the audience at the 2009 Carl Sagan Day celebration at University of Utah.

SHIFT president Jason Cooperrider (far right foreground) sitting with the audience during Belz's presentation.

SHIFT intends to continue celebrating Carl Sagan Day in the future and hopes that many more secular groups and individuals will do so as well. Carl Sagan was a treasure to all of humanity, so he deserves to be honored and remembered as such.


Jason Cooperrider, president and co-founder of SHIFT, holds a BS in neuroscience and a BS in psychology from The Ohio State University. He is pursuing a PhD in neuroscience at the University of Utah.






Learning Activism: My Secular Student Alliance Internship 2009

by Samantha Snyder


Sami Snyder, Fall 2009 Secular Student Alliance intern

It's in a dungeon. That was my first thought as I timidly made my way through the basement of an office building, searching for the headquarters of the Secular Student Alliance. I knew I was in the right place when I saw the dry erase board with a picture of the Flying Spaghetti Monster saying "Howdy!" I was just starting my internship at the Secular Student Alliance for the 2009 Autumn quarter. It was to be a very unique experience: I met a lot of new people, felt like I made a difference helping nontheistic student groups, learned excellent professional skills, and tasted just how amazing Graeter's ice cream is.

Most of my tasks involved updating the Secular Student Alliance website. Some of the projects I helped with included updating affiliates' information, editing and creating pages for speakers and groups, and contacting groups about events happening in their areas. Perhaps my favorite task was editing the Facebook page for the Secular Student Alliance. I added and organized photos, installed useful applications, synched events to the Secular Student Alliance Google Calendar, and many of the same things people love to do on their own Facebook pages. Upkeep on the Internet resources is extremely important. It's the fastest way to acquire information and its networking ability is unsurpassable.

This internship was important to me because students are the next generation in the nontheistic movement, and we have a lot of untapped resources. Many young adult skeptics out there don't even know that groups and organizations such as the Secular Student Alliance exist. During my internship, I learned about outreach techniques and how to keeping a group alive and active. After my internship, my main goal as a student is to let other nontheists know they aren't alone. The Secular Student Alliance gave me the skills and information to help me achieve my goal.

Working with the Secular Student Alliance is definitely an ideal internship for a nontheistic student activist. Not only does the Secular Student Alliance lend its own support, it also provides information about many other organizations that are more than willing to help out student groups. The people I met and the friends I made are absolutely priceless. The experiences I take away from these three months have made me a better leader and community member.

Samantha Snyder was one of two interns at the Secular Student Alliance in the fall of 2009.





Debate on God Attracts Hundreds of Students

This story originally appeared in The Gateway, the official student newspaper at the University of Alberta, on 2/2/2010 , and is used by permission. Article by Dan McKechnie.

Massimo PigliucciCALL TO RATIONALITY
Pigliucci argues on the Horowitz stage last Thursday. Photo by Dan McKechnie
The Myer Horowitz Theatre was host to a centuries-old debate on January 28, as "Does God Exist II" was presented by the University of Alberta Atheist and Agnostic Society and the U of A chapter of Campus for Christ.
Nearly 600 students packed the theatre, eager to hear the discussion about the nature of morality. The debate asked if morality needed to originate from a god, or some other outside organizing force.
On the "no" side was Massimo Pigliucci, the chair of philosophy at Lehman College, part of the City University of New York. He was contracted through the Student Secular Alliance. Pigluicci has published a number of books discussing creationism, rationalism, and evolution.
Arguing for "yes," Michael Horner is an anthropologist who tours Canadian campuses to "promote and defend Christianity," according to his website. He is affiliated with Campus Crusade for Christ, Campus for Christ's governing body. Horner is the author of a number of articles relating to Christian philosophy.
Pigliucci presented an argument against objective morality centering on a Socratic dialogue referred to as "Euthyphro's dilemma": is something moral because God says so, or does God approve of something because because it is moral?
Pigluicci claimed that the first case implied a "might makes right" scenario, which, according to him, does not bear out through history. The second case, Pigliucci said, implied that morality existed separate from God and thereby was not dependent on him.
During his opening arguments, Horner worked from the premise that objective moral principles exist independent of humanity, and on the basis of this assumption, argued that there must be something larger than humanity from whence morality originates.
"Objective moral principles are true, independent of anyone's opinion," he said.
Horner argued that because we intuit, with great consistency, that things like rape and murder are wrong, there must be some manner of universal moral principle.
The debate became heated when the speakers were allowed to speak freely, with both Pigliucci and Horner talking over one another and throwing arguments and rebuttals back and forth. This marked a dramatic change from the sedate pace of the debate up to that point. There was much applause for each speaker in turn as they brought new arguments to bear.
UAAA administrator Farid Iskander said he would like to see similar topics discussed more often.
"While the debate about morality started as early as Socrates, nowadays it's not discussed nearly as much as it should [be]," Iskander said, adding that the goal of the debate is to "engage people in thinking about a topic that is important."
Melanie Joy, a Campus For Christ member involved in organizing the debate, also touched on that sentiment.
"I hope that from the arguments presented, and the discussions following between friends, that students will have their ideas challenged, and refined," she said, adding that another debate may take place next year.
© Copyright 2010 The Gateway/Dan McKechnie





"Good Without God" a Good Idea? "Yes," says Sharon Moss

by Sharon Moss
Good Without GodI've been around the philosophical block a number of times. As a life-long atheist and an activist with 10 years of group-running experience under my belt, I feel like I've heard most of the arguments in our community. I don't read many books on atheism/humanism/insert-other-labels-here anymore. I almost didn't even pick up a copy of Greg Epstein's Good Without God: What a Billion Nonreligious People Do Believe . But I'm glad I did. Epstein covers new ground and provides important, thought-provoking points for the movement.

What piqued my interest was the teaser line on the cover: "Finding purpose, compassion, and community". At a point in my life where I feel like I've been over-exposed to the religion-is-evil meme, these words gave me pause.

There is no shortage of philosophical discussion in our movement. Indeed, Epstein notes that we nontheists "have learned to do two things extremely well over the past century-to speak and to debate." While Epstein spends the first five chapters taking the reader on a journey though the history and ethics of Humanism, he brings to the table a different way of crafting the message of nonbelief. Many excellent reviews have already been written in support of, or opposition to, Epstein's claims in those chapters.

Good Without God appeals to a different audience. While the prominent atheist authors known as the Four Horsemen gave atheists the courage to speak out and demand recognition, Good Without God gives us a place to start a different conversation with each other: What do we do now? Where do we turn when we have thrown off the shackles of god belief but still hunger for community?

Chapter six is entirely dedicated to the idea of building community. As a local group leader, I am aware of the variety of belief that exists in my group. Even though we are called The Humanist Community of Central Ohio, not all our members whole-heartedly embrace the term Humanist. We have those who label themselves as atheists, secular humanists, religious humanists, agnostics, skeptics, and even the occasional liberal Christian who just happens to feel like we're a good fit. We're a motley crew. So it struck a chord to see Epstein accurately describe the same struggles we face with building community. He calls out national and local groups that have shied away from community building. I admit to having said, "Hell yeah!" out loud.

Despite the different ways we arrived at our nonbelief, the folks in my group come together. We celebrate life's highs together and support each other through life's lows. If there's a lesson to take away from Good Without God, it is that these things matter just as much, if not more, than all the intellectual debate we can muster.

If our message is going to reach beyond just white men-to get the majority of nontheists off the couch and into our movement-we need to get our faces out of the philosophy books from time to time. We can take cues from other movements and embrace both our firebrands and our diplomats. It takes all kinds-and different points of entry-to make a movement. Good Without God is a push to get us there.
Sharon MossSharon Moss graduated from The Ohio State University in 2005 with a BA in Comparative Religion. She's a former president of Students for Freethought at Ohio State and a former Secular Student Alliance Board member. She currently lives in Columbus, OH, where she continues to kick secular butt as the president of the Humanist Community of Central Ohio.





"Good Without God" a Good Idea? "No," says Frank Bellamy

by Frank Bellamy

Good Without GodWhen I picked up this book, I didn't have high expectations. Even those expectations were not met. Greg Epstein's Good Without God: What a Billion Nonreligious People Do Believe disappointed me with its use of the sort of fallacious reasoning we nontheists routinely have to refute from religious people.
Epstein's basic philosophy is outlined in Chapter 3: "Why Be Good Without a God." There, he attempts a bad line of argumentation more commonly found in christian writing (the lowercase letter is intentional). First, he tells us that we all need one single, unified purpose of life. Then, Epstein lists many things that he doesn't consider his preferred purposes of for one reason or another. Finally, he tells us what he believes the preferred purpose of life is-and claims that it is the only life purpose that can satisfy our needs.
For Epstein, the purpose of life turns out to be dignity rather than god, but he uses the same reasoning as many christian leaders use. As a result, he makes two of the same errors they do. There's no reason to assume that we each need one single, unified purpose for life. One person may have many different purposes in his or her life. Interestingly, once the reader asks what dignity really is, it doesn't meet Epstein's own standard for a life purpose. Epstein never gives a clear definition of dignity, but every attempted definition consists of concern for one's self and concern for others. Both aspects are important, but combining them under the word "dignity" doesn't create a unitary purpose, especially considering that Epstein rejected each of them separately earlier in the chapter.
The book sinks to its lowest point in the chapter on pluralism. Epstein spends most of the section confusing the believer with the belief, a mistake which can only harm the cause of pluralism. Epstein opens the chapter by attacking what he alleges is the so-called new atheists' view of religious people: that they are poison and ought to be hated or destroyed. As anyone who has read books by these prominent atheist authors would know, none of them actually hold this view. Sam Harris' book is titled The End of Faith, not The End of the Faithful. Christopher Hitchens wrote that religion poisons everything, not that the religious are poisonous, as Epstein seems to attribute to him.
A couple of pages later Epstein commits the same error in the opposite direction, confusing dislike of humanism for dislike of humanists. As he puts it, "It is hard to like those who don't like Humanism, who don't like atheism, who would discriminate against me, who would be prejudiced." But one can dislike humanism while liking some humanists, just as many humanists dislike christianity while liking some christians. Pluralism isn't about forced respect for other people's beliefs; it's about being able to dislike other people's beliefs while appreciating the individual.
A troubling theme in Epstein's writing is his repeated attempts (including his decision to capitalize the word "humanism") to claim for humanism the same privileged status that religion has in American society. In an interview, he said "any protection that you are going to give to a religion under law you need to give us the same." One of the big purposes of the nontheistic movement, of having organizations and meetings, is precisely to undermine and ultimately abolish the privileged status of religion, not to adopt it for ourselves.
These are only a few of the misconceptions to be found in Epstein's book. But what makes Good Without God offensive to me is that unlike the "new atheists" (as he calls them), who do not claim to represent all secular people, Epstein has the arrogance to claim he speaks for you, me, and everyone else who does not believe in a god (see the subtitle). He clearly does not. I agree with PZ Myers, who said, "just as we can be good without god, we can also be good without rituals, good without sacraments, [and] good without priests and chaplains."

Frank Bellamy photoFrank Bellamy is a graduate student in cognitive science at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, the president of the Secular Student Alliance at RPI, and the content manager of the eMpirical.






IFYC Accepting Applications for The Fellows Alliance



The Fellows Alliance is a year-long paid fellowship program by Interfaith Youth Core. It is open to current undergraduates who are committed to organizing interfaith activities and making interfaith cooperation a social norm on their campus. IFYC provides mentorship, a stipend, skill-based trainings, a network of peer colleagues, an alumni network, access to a national network of interfaith organizers and partner organizations, and professional development opportunities.

IFYC welcomes current Freshmen, Sophomores, and Juniors from all majors and religious and philosophical traditions to apply. The ideal candidate has had prior experience with service-learning, has played a leadership role in a campus club or campaign, and has a passion for building a movement on campus.

The application can be found on the website at www.ifyc.org/fellows

For any questions please contact FArecruitment@ifyc.org

Applications are due March 15th and applicants are accepted on a rolling basis. Please apply now!




The Secular Student Alliance Logo

For more information, visit secularstudents.org.

If you are having trouble viewing this E-Mail, it can be viewed on our website.
Facebook! Twitter! YouTube!
Powered by Drupal